I started today with version 1.0.18 and I have the same problem. The role community members is programmed as Automatically approve, but when subscribed it is listed as Awaiting Review, which I can not confirm as admin.
The other question is: Only my own profile appears on the Members page. No new registered (test)members, and no existing members. How can I get all community members on this page? (They all have the role: Community member.